Skip to content

Zillow vs Realtor: Comparing Online Real Estate Giants

Zillow vs Realtor: Comparing Online Real Estate Giants

zillow vs realtor

In the world of online real estate, Zillow and Realtor.com stand as two of the most visited websites by buyers, sellers, and agents. Each platform offers many tools and services to facilitate the complex process of real estate transactions. While Zillow is known for its extensive property database and Zillow Zestimates home value feature, Realtor.com boasts a direct connection to the Multiple Listing Services (MLS) and a focus on professional real estate expertise.

zillow vs realtor

Choosing the right platform is the best way and can significantly impact a user’s real estate journey, whether they are purchasing their first home or listing a property for sale.

The debate over Zillow vs Realtor focuses on various aspects such as lead quality, cost, listing accuracy, and the overall user experience. Each has unique advantages, with Zillow attracting more traffic and offering innovative features and Realtor.com maintaining a reputation for reliability and professional connections in the industry.

As the real estate market continues to evolve, the comparison between these two online giants is more relevant than ever. Property agents, homebuyers, and sellers aim to leverage each other’s strengths to maximize their success in getting the best leads, making an informed choice critical. Understanding the differences between Zillow vs Realtor in business models, listing sources, and additional features is essential for anyone navigating the internet’s vast real estate landscape.

Real Estate Industry Overview

A bustling city skyline with Zillow and Realtor logos towering over various real estate properties: Zillow vs Realtor

The real estate business in the United States is experiencing shifts due to technological advancements and changing consumer behaviors. Key players such as Zillow and Realtor.com are significantly influencing market trends and competition.

Key Players: Zillow vs Realtor

Zillow and Realtor.com are heavyweights in the real estate industry, leveraging extensive data sources of property listings to capture market share. According to available data, Zillow attracts numerous Zillow leads through its pay-per-impression advertising model. In contrast, Realtor.com is known for high-quality leads due to its targeted programs for pre-qualified buyers, though this comes at elevated costs per lead.

Market Trends and Competition

The competitive online real estate marketplace is evolving, with the top platforms Zillow vs Realtor vying for dominance in terms of market share and user engagement. Recent insights suggest Zillow holds a substantial market share of 36.60%, with Realtor.com following at a considerable distance. On the user engagement front, statistics point out that Zillow experiences a greater number of visits and pageviews compared to Realtor.com, highlighting its potent online presence. These trends indicate an intensifying competition where strategic online marketing and lead generation capabilities are crucial for winning real estate professionals’ loyalty and consumer trust.

What is Zillow?

Zillow, founded in 2006 in Seattle, is a popular real estate website offering a platform for buyers, sellers, and renters to explore properties. It provides a database of homes, including images and details, both on and off the market.

One of Zillow’s standout features is its “Zestimates,” which estimate a home’s value based on its tax history. This allows users to compare a home’s listed price with Zillow’s estimate, helping sellers set a fair price. Additionally, Zillow offers a Mortgage Calculator to estimate potential mortgage payments, factoring in PMI, property tax, and other costs.

Zillow Premier Agent

Another noteworthy aspect of Zillow is its Premier Agent, a specialized service for agents, teams, and brokers. This tool, accessible through both web and app interfaces, aims to simplify the communication process between realtors and potential clients.

Premier Agent grants agents and brokers instant access to active buyers and sellers from Zillow’s main databases, facilitating quicker interactions. It also provides various client management (CRM) tools, buyer insights, and performance tracking features.

What is Realtor?

When comparing Zillow vs Realtor, a key distinction is Realtor’s focus on serving agents rather than consumers. Unlike Zillow, which primarily functions as a platform for listing properties, Realtor operates as a database of leads for agents to connect with potential clients.

Realtor is designed to cater to both buyers and sellers, with its database consisting of submissions from interested parties. However, unlike Zillow, individuals cannot directly post listings on Realtor. The platform is backed by the National Association of Realtors (NAR), requiring listings to be processed through agents.

Similar to Zillow, Realtor provides home valuations based on factors such as location and zip code. One of Realtor’s paid features allows agents to pay for exclusive access to leads in a specific zip code, which can cost around $1,000 a month. While this feature is expensive, it can be valuable for agents focusing on a particular niche market.

Realtor offers both free and paid models at various price points. It has gained a reputation as one of the top real estate lead generation websites and a premier directory for agents and realtors.

The Comparison of Zillow vs Realtor

  1. Website Features and User Experience
  2. Services for Buyers and Sellers
  3. Agent Tools and Lead Generation
  4. Pricing and Revenue Models
  5. Accuracy and Reliability of Information
  6. Marketing and Advertising Strategy

1. Website Features and User Experience

A split-screen comparison of Zillow vs Realtor websites, with clear visual differences in layout, search functionality, and listing presentation

When comparing Zillow vs Realtor, one of the key differences is their website features and functionality. It is essential to assess the features each platform offers to facilitate property searches, the accessibility and functionality of their mobile applications, and the overall ease of navigation and user interface of their most popular real estate websites.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Search Functionality and Listings

Zillow provides users with comprehensive search tools, leveraging its vast database drawn from the MLS (Multiple Listing Service). It offers detailed filters that help refine searches to match specific criteria, such as price range, number of bedrooms, and more. On the other hand, Realtor.com also presents a wide array of listings with various search options but emphasizes the timeliness and accuracy of its data, as it has a direct relationship with the National Association of Realtors.

  • Filter options on both sites include:
    • Price
    • Size
    • Type of home
    • Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
Mobile App Accessibility

Both Zillow and Realtor.com have mobile real estate apps that enable users to access real estate valuable information on-the-go. Zillow’s app is notable for its user-friendly design and additional features like the “Zestimate” tool, which provides an estimated market value of homes. Realtor.com’s mobile app is praised for its functionality and efficient user experience, which often results in accurate and up-to-date listings equivalent to their website experience.

  • App featuresfor both platforms may include:
    • Instant notifications: Get alerts when new listings match your criteria or when there are updates to your favorite properties.
    • Map search: View properties in a map view to explore different neighborhoods.
User Interface and Navigation

The website comparison of Zillow vs Realtor is designed with the user in mind. Zillow offers a clean and simple layout, which makes finding properties straightforward. In contrast, Realtor.com’s interface is structured to deliver fast load times and easy access to home value estimations. Both platforms ensure their users experience minimal difficulties when navigating through the vast amounts of real estate information available.

  • Navigation elements are typically found on their websites:
    • Home search bar: Prominently featured for immediate access to listings.
    • Menu categories: Well-organized to help users find tools and resources quickly.

2. Services for Buyers and Sellers

Buyers and sellers compare Zillow vs Realtor services

When considering Zillow vs Realtor, both platforms offer distinctive services that cater to the needs of buyers and sellers in the real estate market, focusing on areas such as agent connections, listing exposure, FSBO listings, and instant offers.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Agent Connections and Listings Exposure

Both Zillow and Realtor.com provide agent directories where buyers and sellers can find and connect with real estate professionals in their area. Zillow leverages its vast user base to help sellers gain exposure for their homes by listing them on the platform, potentially reaching a large audience quickly. For buyers, this means access to a broad set of listings including those posted by agents and FSBO properties.

Realtor.com, on the other hand, focuses on offering high-quality leads through targeted programs, which might lead to sales with a pre-qualified buyer, ensuring that agents are connected with serious prospective buyers.

FSBO Listings and Instant Offers

Regarding For-Sale-By-Owner (FSBO) listings, Zillow includes them in its search results, providing homeowners a way to market their home for sale without an agent. This can be an attractive option for sellers looking to save on commissions. However, it is important to note that only a small percentage of sellers actually finalize a sale without any agent involvement.

Zillow also extends its services with Zillow Offers, an instant offer service where sellers may receive a cash offer from Zillow itself. This service simplifies the process by giving a speedy transaction option for sellers preferring an immediate sale over a potentially prolonged market listing period. Buyers, particularly investors, may find opportunities in these instant offers as well.

3. Agent Tools and Lead Generation

A laptop displaying Zillow vs  Realtor websites, surrounded by agent tools like phone, notebook, and pen. Leads and contacts organized on a desk

The real estate sector exploits technology for efficient lead generation, where platforms like Zillow and Realtor.com provide distinctive tools and services. These tools are pivotal for agents seeking to amplify their visibility and client base, directly impacting lead quality and conversion rates.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Premier Agent Program

Zillow’s Premier Agent Program is designed to bolster agents’ capacities for capturing leads by offering exclusive placement on listings. The program includes lead capture forms to facilitate direct interactions with potential buyers. This enables agents to effectively engage with prospects and subsequently escalate their chances of conversion.

Lead Quality and Conversion

When it comes to lead quality and conversion, Realtor.com and Zillow present different advantages. An agent’s cost on Zillow can range from $20 to $60 per 1,000 impressions, with a conversion rate expectation of about 4% of the leads who initiate contact. Conversely, agents on Realtor.com may experience different costs and capture rates, emphasizing the necessity of a tailored approach to each platform for maximizing lead generation efficacy.

4. Pricing and Revenue Models

A scale balancing money bags between Zillow vs Realtor logos

The real estate platforms Zillow and Realtor.com deploy distinct pricing and revenue models that cater to various user preferences and needs in the vastly competitive digital marketplace.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Subscription Fees

Zillow and Realtor.com offer differing subscription-based models for their services. On Realtor.com, agents may encounter non-exclusive leads starting at $200 monthly, with exclusive leads climbing to $1,000. In contrast, Zillow’s charges for leads can vary, often ranging from $20 to $60 per lead, contingent on several factors including regional median home prices and market saturation.

Commission and Flex Program

Realtor.com typically derives part of its revenue from referral fees linked to successful transactions, where agents may pay a commission upon closing a deal secured through the platform. Meanwhile, Zillow had implemented a “Flex program” that aligns agent payments with successful sales, where they pay a commission to Zillow rather than upfront fees for leads. This program intends to offer a return on investment (ROI) that is more directly tied to actual sales, potentially benefiting agents who close deals more frequently.

5. Accuracy and Reliability of Information

A scale with "Zillow vs Realtor" on opposite ends, balanced evenly, with a magnifying glass hovering above, symbolizing accuracy and reliability

When considering Zillow and Realtor.com, the core focus for users is often the accuracy and reliability of home value estimates. These platforms offer vital data which can significantly affect the decision-making process of buyers and sellers.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Home Value Estimates and Price Accuracy

Zillow is known for its “Zestimate,” an estimated market value for a home. Zestimate calculations are based on a proprietary formula incorporating public and user-submitted data. The accuracy of Zestimate is often expressed through a median error rate, which means that half of the Zestimates are closer than the error margin and half are further away. For on-market homes, Zillow claims to have a median error rate of around 2%. However, for off-market homes, the error rate may be higher.

Realtor.com, on the other hand, uses MLS (Multiple Listing Service) data, which is widely regarded to be more accurate since it’s updated by real estate professionals. Users can be more confident of the price estimates on Realtor.com reflecting the most current market trends due to this direct input from real estate agents. The presence of real-time updates from MLS can mean that Realtor.com’s home value estimates have a strong reliability metric, which is paramount in the realm of real estate accuracy.

In summation, while both Zillow and Realtor.com provide valuable home value estimates, users should be aware of the methodologies and potential error rates when utilizing these figures to inform their real estate decisions.

6. Marketing and Advertising Strategy

A graphic of real estate digital advertising and marketing strategies

When comparing Zillow vs Realtor, their marketing and advertising strategies leverage various tools designed to capture leads and offer exclusive opportunities to real estate professionals. These platforms harness the power of targeted advertising, sophisticated analytics, and comprehensive marketing tools to provide valuable impressions that can evolve into potential sales leads.

Pros and Cons of Zillow vs Realtor

Paid Advertising and Exclusive Leads

Zillow vs Realtor for paid advertising and exclusive leads. Zillow offers an advertising platform known as Zillow Premier Agent which is structured around paid advertising. Real estate agents can advertise on Zillow to connect with active buyers, utilize marketing tools, and potentially gain exclusive leads. Costs can be significant, requiring a solid return on investment, but the leads provided can be diverse in quality.

  • Cost Structure: Agents typically pay for impressions, recommended at a monthly minimum to maintain visibility.
  • Lead Quality: While some leads are highly qualified, agents may also receive unqualified leads, necessitating careful vetting.

In contrast, Realtor employs a different approach where leads are also monetized, but with a focus on traditional real estate marketing practices. Agents purchase leads or advertising space, with the platform fostering connections between buyers, sellers, and real estate professionals.

  • Exclusive Leads: Agents receive leads that might not be available through other sources, contributing to exclusivity.
  • Analytics and Tools: The platform provides agents with analytics to gauge the effectiveness of their advertising and manage their investments accordingly.

Both platforms have their own unique marketing mix, with Zillow focusing more on paid ad impressions and premier agent exclusivity, while Realtor combines traditional and digital strategies to offer a robust advertising solution for real estate professionals.

Real Estate Agent Perspective: Zillow vs Realtor

A real estate agent compares Zillow vs Realtor websites, with a laptop and smartphone on a desk, surrounded by house keychains and property brochures

When considering Zillow vs Realtor, it’s essential for agents to analyze how these platforms influence their business in terms of lead generation, the type of leads obtained, and their ultimate impact on commission earnings.

The Impact of Zillow vs Realtor on Agent Business

Lead Generation: Real estate professionals rely on various sources for generating potential client leads. Zillow, with its significant web traffic, offers a broad audience and a high volume of leads, which are non-exclusive and available to any agent who is part of their network. Conversely, Realtor.com provides connections through their Connections Plus system that may lead to exclusive leads, allowing agents to foster a more direct relationship with potential clients.

Lead Quality and Conversion: The varying quality of leads from these platforms can affect an agent’s time and resources. Leads from Zillow can range widely in quality, which necessitates careful vetting by agents to find qualified prospects. On the other hand, Realtor.com leads may require less vetting as they might come with more detailed information. The conversion of a lead into a paying client is the ultimate goal and will affect an agent’s commission.

Agent-Client Relationships: Establishing a strong agent-client relationship is crucial, and the platform, Zillow vs Realtor, can influence this dynamic. Agents need to consider which platform aligns with their marketing strategy and offers the best potential for maintaining and developing client relationships.

Costs and ROI: Agents pay for premium services on platforms like Zillow through subscriptions, which has a direct impact on their return on investment (ROI). The cost versus benefit ratio must be evaluated to determine if the expense leads to a profitable increase in converted leads and commissions. Real estate agents must weigh these costs to ensure they invest in the most beneficial platform for their business.

Learn More About eXp Realty & Our Free Partnership Team!

Join our eXp Realty Team!
Join Our Team for Free for the most resources and collaboration for your success!

If you are interested in joining the best brokerage for agent growth, compensation, and opportunity in the world, be sure to partner with the best sponsorship team in the world as well! We provide additional training, tools, coaching, partners, collaboration, masterminds, and resources for your success!

We believe in massive growth and financial freedom for all real estate agents! Live your dream real estate lifestyle with us.

For more eXp Realty details, check out our comprehensive About eXp Realty – Everything You Need to Know article.